"El Asedio a la Modernidad" is a significant work for several reasons. First, it provides a comprehensive and systematic critique of the intellectual and cultural trends that have been undermining modernity. Sebreli's analysis is characterized by its clarity, rigor, and depth, making the book an essential resource for anyone interested in understanding the complexities of modernity.
While celebrated for its "originality and methodological coherence," some critics argue that Sebreli falls into the very trap he critiques. Some reviewers in academic journals like Dialnet note that by defining the issue as a "clash of values," he adopts a relativist model himself, turning his defense of modernity into a "moralizing crusade". Juan Jose Sebreli El Asedio A La Modernidad Pdf 33
“Modernity is not a doctrine to defend, but a wound to keep open.” "El Asedio a la Modernidad" is a significant
Sebreli identifies several key enemies of modernity, including relativism, historicism, and the ideology of "difference." He argues that these intellectual currents have contributed to a corrosive skepticism about the possibility of objective truth and a growing intolerance for dissenting opinions. Sebreli also critiques the excesses of postmodernism, which he sees as a philosophical and cultural movement that has undermined the authority of reason and the notion of universal values. Sebreli also critiques the excesses of postmodernism, which
El asedio a la modernidad (Buenos Aires, Editorial Sudamericana, 1991; later reissued) is one of Juan José Sebreli’s most ambitious books. Sebreli (b. 1930) is a prominent Argentine philosopher, sociologist, and cultural critic, associated with critical rationalism and a fierce defender of modernity against postmodernism, relativism, and certain strains of the Frankfurt School.
